top of page
Search

Who’s Liable for Bad Plans?

16 minutes ago
4 min read

Picture this: your crew shows up ready to pour, follows the plans to the letter, and three weeks later you're ripping out concrete because the design didn't work. Sound familiar? If you've ever built exactly what the plans told you to build and still ended up eating the cost of a fix, you already understand why it’s important that the law put some responsibility for bad plans on the party that drew them up: the Owner and its Architect.


Plans and specifications that are wrong can blow up a project's budget and schedule fast. The good news is that when an Owner hands a Contractor a set of plans and specs to bid and build from, the law treats the Owner as impliedly guaranteeing that those plans and specs are correct. This comes from a legal theory courts call “Breach of Implied Warranty of Correctness of Plans and Specifications,” and it's been part of California construction law for decades. But knowing the theory exists and actually winning on it are two different things, and a Contractor has to prove several elements to collect.


(1) Element one: you have to be following someone else's design


This part is usually easy. You just have to show the Owner gave you the plans and specs, that you were required to follow them, and that they turned out to be wrong. One catch: if you're a design-build contractor, you likely can't bring this claim at all, since you're the one who created the design in the first place.


(2) Element two: your reliance has to be reasonable


Simply following the plans isn't automatically enough. You have to show it was reasonable to rely on them when you bid the job. If the plans had defects so obvious that any competent Contractor would have caught them, a court may decide you should have known better, and your claim can fall apart right there. This is why red flags in the plans are worth flagging in writing before you bid, not after.


(3) Element three: the bad plans actually cost you money


This is where these claims live or die. It's not enough to say “I estimated X, it cost me Y, so the plans must be why.” You have to prove your estimate was sound and that nothing else (not your own inefficiencies, not your own or subcontractors' delays, not weather, not anything) contributed to the overrun. Juries and judges know no Contractor is perfect, so claiming you were flawless usually backfires. Contractors who own up to the part of the overrun that was genuinely their fault, and pin the rest squarely on the bad plans, come across as far more credible, and credibility is often what wins these cases.


Watch Out For “You Should Have Caught It” Clauses


Plenty of contracts include language requiring the Contractor to certify that it carefully reviewed the plans before signing, but depending on the actual language, that clause alone may or may not make the Contractor responsible for bad plans. On public works, the California Public Contract Code goes further and actually prohibits a contract from making the Contractor responsible: “No local public entity, charter city, or charter county shall require a bidder to assume responsibility for the completeness and accuracy of architectural or engineering plans and specifications on public works projects, except on clearly designated design build projects.” But the contract can still require that the Contractor review the plans and report any errors and omissions to the Owner or Architect.


Another Type of Claim: When the Owner Knew Something and Didn't Tell You


Another, related claim arises when an Owner withholds information it had, rather than handing over plans that were simply wrong. Here, you have to prove that you submitted your bid without information that affected your cost to do the work, that the Owner had that information and knew you didn't have it and had no reason to go find it, and that the Owner simply never shared it. You don't need to prove the Owner was trying to pull a fast one; negligent silence counts just as much as deliberate concealment.


You also have to show that the plans, specs, or other information the Owner did give you either misled you or didn't put you on notice to dig deeper. And, as always, you need to show you were actually harmed by the Owner's silence.


The California Supreme Court has tackled this exact claim and explained that whether a Contractor can recover turns on the totality of the circumstances. Things like any warranties or disclaimers in the contract, what the plans and related documents actually showed, how hard the condition would have been to detect, any bidding time pressure the Owner imposed, and whether the Contractor made assumptions it shouldn't have factor into who will be responsible. The bottom line from the Court: an Owner isn't liable for failing to disclose something a reasonably diligent Contractor would or should have found on its own, but the Owner can be on the hook when it knew, or should have known, that even a careful, responsible Contractor would be unlikely to uncover the problem before it drove up the cost of the job.


Don't Sit On It – Notice Is Key


No matter which theory applies or when you first suspect something's off with the plans, check your contract. Most all contracts and subcontracts require you to promptly notify the Owner the moment you spot a problem, before you plow ahead and start racking up the extra costs these claims are built to recover. Flag it in writing, flag it fast, and you protect both the claim and your bottom line.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page